PARK WATCH Article November 2026 |

From mysterious marine slugs to museum collections, a community of nudi nerds is helping piece together the puzzle reports Kade Mills, ReefWatch Coordinator 

We often take the names of wildlife for granted. A bird, a tree, a fish, a sea slug – we learn what to call them and rarely give it another thought.

But what happens when you encounter an animal that has no place in the books? Is it a species nobody has described, a familiar animal masquerading as something else, or a creature no one has seen before?

This is the kind of mystery that keeps participants coming back to Victoria’s Sea Slug Census. Eight years of searching have revealed an extraordinary diversity of marine life, but also a surprising number of sea slugs (aka nudibranchs) that remain unidentified, unnamed or in taxonomic limbo.

The closer we look, the more we realise how much of the life beneath our waves is still waiting to be understood.

When a name isn’t the answer

Over the eight years of the Sea Slug Census, we’ve recorded an extraordinary diversity of animals. But more than 130 species (almost half of the over 300 found during the census so far) remain only provisionally identified, unnamed or awaiting taxonomic revision. Some may be new to science; others may be familiar to a handful of specialists but remain poorly documented. Either way, the continual discovery prompted a conversation among some of our slug enthusiasts – how do we name the unnamed? What started as a simple question soon grew into a collaborative effort to tackle the taxonomic tangle.

For ReefWatchers Nick Shaw, John Olden and Ian Scholey, simply recording these unusual animals wasn’t enough. They wanted to help unravel sea slug taxonomy. We can find these slugs, photograph them and recognise that they don’t seem to fit neatly into the field guides, but what happened next? How could these findings be turned into names and contribute to scientific knowledge?

I had to admit I was well out of my depth, so I approached Museums Victoria to find out how we might take the next step. It turned out the right people and expertise were already within reach, and what began as a desire to solve a few sea slug mysteries grew into a remarkable collaborative effort.

A taxonomic basket case

Animal taxonomy – the science of identifying, naming and classifying organisms – can be a bit of a basket case for some groups of animals. Names are always changing, groups are being split up then put back together and taxonomists are known to disagree. DNA analyses turned up with a bigger basket, a few more questions, and a problem which tipped the whole thing upside down.

For centuries, scientists classified animals by examining what they can see: an animal’s morphology, that is its size, shape, colour patterns and anatomy. Additional information such as behaviour and development also help. This approach has taught us an enormous amount, but evolution doesn’t always follow the neat filing system we’ve invented for it.

Distantly-related animals can independently evolve remarkably similar features, while close relatives can look quite different. Similarities may reflect shared ancestry or the independent evolution of traits in response to similar environmental pressures – a process known as convergent evolution. Working out which is which can be tough, and it’s one reason why scientists sometimes need genetic evidence, as well as physical appearance, to unravel evolutionary relationships.

Enter DNA sequencing, which has given scientists another way to unravel evolutionary relationships. Genetic evidence can reveal connections that physical appearance alone might miss, uncover cryptic species – distinct species that look almost identical – and help resolve relationships that have puzzled taxonomists for decades.

But DNA is a double-edged sword. Rather than neatly sorting every species into its rightful place, genetic analysis can reveal unexpected complications. Different genes can tell different evolutionary stories, while processes such as hybridisation and the persistence of ancestral genetic variation can make relationships harder to untangle.

And just when scientists think they’re getting things sorted, closer scrutiny can reveal even more diversity. What was once considered a single species may turn out to be several. Groups once lumped together may need splitting, while others may be brought back together. Names change, classifications shift, and yesterday’s settled science becomes tomorrow’s taxonomic headache.

DNA hasn’t made taxonomy a basket case. It’s revealed just how complicated the basket always was. Our classifications are attempts to make sense of an evolutionary history far messier and more fascinating than the labels we give it. And for sea slug enthusiasts who keep finding animals that don’t quite fit those labels, this is where the mystery becomes an opportunity.

A sea slug legend and a fortunate connection

As luck would have it, Audrey and Leon from the Victorian Field Naturalists Club’s Marine Research Group were already working to ‘download’ the remarkable knowledge held in the brain of Bob Burn to update his list of sea slugs found in Victoria.

Bob is something of a sea slug legend. A third-generation builder, he has helped shape his hometown of Geelong through his construction work. Yet, I suspect many of the people who employed him never knew that, in his spare time he’s a renowned sea slug taxonomist. He’s described many species and published more than 100 scientific papers, including one in Nature in 1960, when he was a young naturalist. Bob has also been the taxonomic expert helping identify many of the animals found during our Sea Slug Census.

Combining these efforts was the next step. Earlier this year, representatives from the different groups met at Melbourne Museum to discuss how we could begin documenting and investigating some of these elusive animals more systematically.

The idea was to build a collection that links photographs of sea slugs in their natural habitat with laboratory images, DNA information and preserved specimens. Each contributing a different piece of evidence. Together this creates a resource that can be revisited long after the original discovery.

From reef to research collection

So, what actually happens when we find a sea slug that warrants further investigation?

It starts in the field. A ReefWatcher or member of the Marine Research Group spots an interesting animal and photographs it in its natural habitat. These images record its appearance along with its location and other useful observations like depth and what the slug was found living on. Where appropriate and permitted a specimen is collected for closer examination and transported to the laboratory.

In the laboratory, the specimen is photographed again so we can capture details that might be difficult to see underwater, creating a more detailed visual record of the animal.

Next comes the DNA work. A sample is taken from the specimen and processed to extract its DNA. A target section of the DNA is then amplified – essentially making many copies of that section so there’s enough material to sequence. The resulting genetic information can then be examined alongside the photographs, physical characteristics and existing scientific knowledge to help investigate the animal’s identity and evolutionary relationships.

Throughout this process, the specimen itself remains critically important. Once preserved as a museum voucher specimen, it provides a physical reference for future researchers. That way, if new techniques become available, or if it is thought that a species has been misidentified, they can return to the original specimen and reassess the evidence.

The photographs, DNA and preserved animal each tell part of the story:

  • The initial photographs document the slug in its habitat.
  • Laboratory images reveal finer details.
  • Genetic analysis provides a way to investigate identity.
  • The voucher specimen allows the evidence to be independently revisited.

Linking these records together makes the collection far more valuable than any one component alone.

Many hands make light work – and better science

This is where collaboration becomes essential. Getting this done requires permits, an ability to find the slugs, photography, correct specimen handling, laboratory facilities, genetic analysis and taxonomic expertise. No single participant or organisation needs to do everything, but each contributes to move the investigation forward.

Museums Victoria prepares the DNA samples for sequencing. The CSIRO National Biodiversity DNA Library does the sequencing, while members of the Victorian Field Naturalists Club’s Marine Research Group coordinate collection permits, photograph specimens in the laboratory, and manage specimen preservation and storage. ReefWatchers – all of whom are also members of the Marine Research Group – find the slugs, photograph them and collect specimens under permit. Kayden Verhagen, a Deakin University PhD student studying sea slugs, brings research expertise to the collaboration.

It’s a wonderful mix of community discovery, natural history expertise, museum collections, university research and molecular science. Just as importantly, it connects people who might otherwise be working on separate pieces of the same puzzle.

There’s still a huge amount of work ahead. Specimens need to be processed, genetic results analysed, morphology investigated and existing classifications checked. Some animals may eventually prove to be species new to western science; others may help resolve longstanding taxonomic questions. Not every find will lead to a new species description and DNA alone won’t provide all the answers. The value lies in building a body of evidence robust enough to help researchers work out what they’re looking at.

A legacy for future nudi nerds

The real excitement is that this collection will outlast the original discoveries. In the future, researchers may be able to identify an animal that currently defeats us, compare it with a specimen collected elsewhere, or use improved genetic techniques to answer questions we haven’t yet thought to ask.

It’s not hard to imagine that a sea slug photographed on a Victorian reef today will become the subject of a scientific paper years from now. The person who first spotted it may never know how significant their find would become. But their photograph, the specimen collected under permit and the information recorded along the way could provide the starting point for a much bigger discovery.

We’re building a resource not just for today’s researchers, but for future ‘nudi nerds’ – the people who’ll pick up these puzzles long after we’ve moved on to the next rockpool or reef. By preserving the evidence now we’re giving them a better chance of answering tomorrow’s questions.

The Sea Slug Census began by encouraging people to look more closely at the life around them. This collaboration is taking that curiosity a step further by connecting community observations with the people and institutions equipped to help investigate them.

It’s humbling to continually discover how much remains unknown, even in places we’ve searched many times before. Reminding us that nature doesn’t fit neatly into our categories, and that our understanding is always a work in progress.