PARK WATCH Article November 2026 |
Election commitments threatening to return the destructive practice are a pipe dream says Matt Ruchel, Executive Director
Both the Coalition and One Nation have said they want to return native forest logging. There are many ecological, financial and regulatory barriers to returning native forest logging in Victoria. Here are some of the reasons why native forest logging should never return.
Impacts to habitats and wildlife
Repeated studies have shown logging native forests is catastrophic for wildlife, particularly those that depend on tree hollows, like Greater Gliders and Powerful Owls. Logging fragments and degrades habitat, pushing threatened wildlife closer to extinction. It disrupts water systems, reduces carbon storage and once forests are logged, they take hundreds of years to recover.
Native forest logging operates at a financial loss
Native forest logging operated at a financial loss for decades and was largely propped up with taxpayers dollars. At least $1.5 billion has been spent on transitioning the industry away from logging native forests. It makes no economic sense to spend potentially millions of dollars resurrecting an industry that was already completely ecologically and financially unsustainable.
Between 2019 and 2023, the state government owned logging agency VicForests recorded $127 million in losses. Between 2019 and 2024, VicForests relied on $466 million in government financial support.
Native forest logging was propped up by taxpayer funding, and came at a huge cost to some of the most ecologically significant forests on the planet, home to many threatened plants and animals.
Fire and wood supply is gone
Bushfires have repeatedly damaged huge areas of forest in East Gippsland, Central Highlands and across the Victorian Alps, making the area available for logging dramatically decrease if not disappear, a point acknowledged by the Victorian ALP in 2023, and since repeated.
That’s not to mention the impacts on habitats and wildlife those fires and historic logging practices have caused, and that reintroducing logging would exacerbate.
Forests that have been logged are failing to regenerate at an alarming rate. Bringing back native forest logging in a world increasingly impacted by ever more damaging climate change-fuelled events is nonsensical.
Special regulatory treatment no longer exists
The native forest industry always depended on special treatment, especially under national nature laws, and these exemptions have now been removed. Most of the enabling legislation at the state level has also been taken away. While significant loopholes do exist, it’s misleading to announce that the switch can easily be turned back on.
The courts have also repeatedly found native forest logging in Victoria breaches nature laws, despite the significant exceptions it was afforded.
Victoria’s timber industry is strong and vibrant without native forest logging. Before native forest logging ended, the plantation industry already made up 94 per cent of Victoria’s timber industry, with 19 out of 20 trees cut in Victoria already coming from plantations.
The plantation industry continues to grow and it contributes enormously to Victoria’s economy, particularly in rural and regional areas.
There seems to be a purposeful conflation of the native forest industry and plantation sector, yet the two need to be kept very separate if we are to have a coherent approach.
Political parties should focus on polices to achieve a well-managed, ecologically sensitive plantation industry. They need to promote farm forestry, not resurrecting a flawed, damaging and divisive past.
- Read the latest full edition of Park Watch magazine
- Subscribe to keep up-to-date about this and other nature issues in Victoria
- Become a member to receive Park Watch magazine in print
